Accueil > Hausdorff Institute, Invariants L2 > L2-invariants and 3–manifolds, II (Stefan Friedl)

L2-invariants and 3–manifolds, II (Stefan Friedl)

09/10/2016

[mathjax]

Geometrisation

Let \( N \) be a compact, orientable 3–manifold. Say that \( N \) is prime if it cannot be decomposed as the connected sum of two 3–manifolds both not homeomorphic to \( \mathbb S^3 \). (By the Sphere Theorem this is equivalent to \( N \) not containing any sphere not bounding a 3-ball, and \( M \not= \mathbb S^2 \times \mathbb S^2 \).)

An embedded torus \( T \subset N \) is said to be essential if the induced map \( \pi_1(T) \to \pi_1(N) \) is injective. By Papakryakopoulos’ Loop Theorem, if \( N \) is prime this is equivalent to \( T \) not being the boundary of an embeded solid torus.

Geometrisation Theorem (Perelman, conjectured by W. Thurston): Let \( N \) be a prime 3–manifold. Then one of the following holds:

  1. \( N \) is Seifert fibered;
  2. \( N \) is hyperbolic;
  3. \( N \) contains an incompressible torus.

By induction, this implies that every prime 3–manifold contains a finite collection of incompressible tori which cuts it into “geometric pieces”, i.e. manifolds with torus boundary which are either hyperbolic or Seifert fibered. For ou examples of knot exteriors we have:

  • As we saw, the exteriors of the trefoil of 51 are Seifert fibered;
  • The exterior of the figure-eight and of 52 are hyperbolic;
  • The exterior of a Whitehead double contains an essential torus, namely the boundary of the tubular neighbourhood of the original knot. For example this decomposes the exterior of the double of the trefoil into a Seifert fibered piece (the exterior of the trefoil) and an hyperbolic piece.

\( L^2 \)-invariants

\( L^2 \)-Betti numbers

Given a finite CW-complex \( X \) and a morphism \( \gamma: \pi_1(X) \to \Gamma \) for some discrete group \( \Gamma \) we obtain \( L^2 \)-Betti numbers \( b_n^{(2)}(X ; \gamma) \) from the complex
\[
C_*^{(2)}(X ; \gamma) = \ell^2(\Gamma) \otimes_{{\mathbb Z}[\pi_1(X)]} C_*(\widetilde X).
\]
If \( \Gamma \) is residually finite, i.e. there exists a sequence \( \Gamma = \Gamma_0 \supset \Gamma_1 \supset \cdots \) of finite-index, normal subgroups \( \Gamma_i \le \Gamma \) with \( \bigcup_i \Gamma_i = \{ 1 \} \) then an alternative definition is given by:

Lück Approximation Theorem: With the notation above, let \( X_i = \Gamma_i \backslash \widetilde X \). Then:
\[
b_n^{(2)}(X ; \gamma) = \lim_{i \to +\infty} \frac{b_n(X_i)} {|\Gamma/\Gamma_i|}.
\]

Using only this theorem it is possible to prove the following properties of the \( L^2 \)-Betti numbers:

  • If \( \Gamma = \langle x \rangle \cong {\mathbb Z} \) then \( b_n^{(2)}(X; \gamma) = b_n(X ; {\mathbb Q}(x)) \).
  • For any aspherical, prime compact 3–manifold \( N \) we have \( b_*(N ; \pi_1(N) = 0 \).

The proof of the second point follows if we can prove it for geometric manifolds. For Seifert manifolds the fundamental groups are extensions of Fuchsian groups by \( {\mathbb Z} \) and it is easy to find an explicit sequence of finite-index subgroup where \( b_1 \) grows sublinearly in the index.

For hyperbolic manifolds one can use the following deep theorem of Agol :

Theorem: If \( N \) is an hyperbolic manifold there exists a finite cover \( M \to N \) such that \( M \) is a surface bundle over \( \mathbb S^1 \).

The fundamental group is then an extension of \( {\mathbb Z} \) by a surface group, for which it is easy to find a sequence of finite-index subgroup whose first Betti numbers grows sublinearly.

\( L^2 \)-torsion

Suppose that \( N, \gamma \) is \( L^2 \)-acyclic, meaning that the Betti numbers \( b_n^{(2)}(N ; \Gamma) \) are all zero. Then it is possible to define the \( L^2 \)-torsion \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \gamma) \), which is a positive real number (at least if \( \Gamma \) is residually finite).

In the case where the cellular complex is concentrated in one degree, say \( C_2^{(2)} \overset{\partial_2}{\to} C_1^{(2)} \), then the Reidemeister torsion is equal to the Fuglede–Kadison determinant: \( \tau^{(2)} = \det^{(2)}(\partial) \).

For 3–manifolds the universal cover is \( L^2 \)-acyclic, and Geometrisation allows to compute exactly the \( L^2 \)-torsion.

Theorem (Lück–Schick): Let \( N \) be a compact, prime 3–manifold and let \( N_1, \ldots, N_r \) be the hyperbolic pieces in the geometric decomposition of \( N \). Then:
\[
log \tau^{(2)}(N ; \pi_1(N)) = \frac 1 {6\pi} \sum_{i=1}^r \mathrm{vol}(N_i).
\]

The \( L^2 \)-Alexander invariant

Definition

Let \( N \) be a 3–manifold with morphisms \( \gamma: \pi_1(N) \to \Gamma \) and \( \phi: \pi_1(N) \to \langle x \rangle \cong {\mathbb Z} \). We say that the triple \( (N , \gamma, \phi) \) is admissible if \( \phi \) factors through \( \gamma \). In this setting, for \( t \in ]0, +\infty[ \) put:
\[
\tau^{(2)}(N ; \gamma, \phi)(t) = \tau^{(2)}(N ; g \mapsto t^{\phi(g)}\gamma(g)).
\]
The \( L^2 \)-Alexander invariant is the function \( t \mapsto \tau^{(2)}(N ; \gamma, \phi)(t) \). Note that for \( t \not\in{\mathbb Q} \) it is not obvious at all that this is positive, since for this we need to prove that a matrix with coefficients in the group ring \( {\mathbb R}[\Gamma] \) (as opposed to \( {\mathbb Z}[\Gamma] \) in the definition of \( L^2 \)-torsion) is of determinant class.

Baby case: \( \Gamma = {\mathbb Z} \)

Let \( \Gamma = \langle x \rangle \cong {\mathbb Z} \), and consider the admissible triple \( N, \gamma=\phi, \phi) \). For a matrix \( A \in M_{n \times n}({\mathbb R}[x, x^{-1}]) \) the Fuglede–Kadison determinant is given by the Mahler measure of the classical determinant. Namely, \( \det(A) \) is a polynomial in \( x, x^{-1} \) and we have:
\[
\begin{array}{cc}
\det^{(2)}(A) = m(\det(A)) & := \int_{|z|=1} \log|\det(A)(z)| \frac{dz} z \\
& = C\prod_{\det(A)(z_i) = 0} \max(1, |z_i|)
\end{array}
\]
where \( C \) is the leading coefficient of \( \det(A) \).

It is then easy to see that, in the simplest case where the complex is \( {\mathbb Z}[x, x^{-1}]^m \overset{A}{\to} {\mathbb Z}[x, x^{-1}]^n \), that:
\[
\tau^{(2)}(N; \phi, \phi) = Ct^n \prod_{\det(A)(z_i) = 0} \max(1, t^{-1}|z|_i).
\]
We see that \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi) \) is a piecewise polynomial function, in particular \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi) \equiv C \prod_i |z_i| \) in a neighbourhood of 0 and \( \equiv Ct^n \) in a neighbourhood of \( +\infty\).

In this setting the \( L^2 \)-Alexander invariant has many properties similar to the Reidemeister torsion.

  1. If \( N \) is a surface bundle over the circle and \( \phi \) is dual to the fiber then \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi) \equiv 1 \) in a neighbourhood of \( 0 \) and \( \equiv t^k \) for some \( k \ge 0 \) at infinity.
  2. The “degree at infinity” \( k \) is smaller than the Thurson norm of \( \phi \).
  3. The \( L^2 \)-Alexander invariant is “symmetric”, in the sense that \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi)(t^{-1}) = t^k\tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi)(t) \).
  4. If \( N \) is Seifert fibered then \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi)(t) = \max(1, t^{\| \phi \|_T}) \).

\( L^2 \)-Alexander invariant for the universal cover

From now on \( \gamma \) is the identity \( \pi_1(N) \to \pi_1(N) \) and we denote by \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi ) \) the \( L^2 \)-Alexander function \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \gamma, \phi) \).

Theorem (Dubois–Friedl–Lück): Suppose that \( N \) is a fiber bundle over the circle with fiber a surface \( F \) and monodromy \( f \), and \( \phi \) is the class dual to \( F \). Let \( \lambda \) be the dilatation of \( f \) (the largest modulus of an eigenvalue of \( f_*: H_1(F; {\mathbb C}) \to H_1(F; {\mathbb C}) \)). Then \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi)(t) = 1 \) for \( t \le \lambda^{-1} \) and \( \tau^{(2)}(N ; \phi, \phi)(t) = t^{-\chi(F)} \) for \( t \ge \lambda \).

It is not known whether \( \tau^{(2)}(N; \phi) \) can be constant in an interval strictly larger than \( [0, \lambda^{-1}] \).

Other properties of this \( L^2 \)-Alexander function, similar to the ones we saw in other settings, are:

  1. \( \tau^{(2)}(N; \phi) \) is symmetric around \( t = 1 \).
  2. The Fox–Milnor theorem extends to the \( L^2 \)-Alexander function, but it is essentially useless in this setting since every nonnegative function can be written in the form \( t \mapsto f(t)f(t^{-1}) \).

Theorem (G. Hermann): If \( N \) is Seifert fibered then \( \tau^{(2)}(N; \phi)(t) = \max(1, t^{\|\phi\|_T}) \).

Categories: Hausdorff Institute, Invariants L2 Tags:
  1. Pas encore de commentaire
Les commentaires sont fermés.